Great ideas feel like they blossom.

· Bits and Bobs 11/4/25
  • Great ideas feel like they blossom.
    • The initial seed of the idea is a discontinuity: a surprise.
    • But then every follow-on thought feels natural; obvious in retrospect.
      • Even if it's initially surprising, after a moment's thought it snaps into place with an "of course!".
      • It expands and unfurls almost on its own.
    • Bad ideas have lots of discontinuities, lots of points where the listener goes, "wait, what?" or even "wait, that doesn't make any sense."
    • Sometimes you lose the listener completely.
      • They are game over on the argument.
      • They give up and go elsewhere.
      • Sometimes you can win them back, with some effort.
      • It's a friction point.
    • So great ideas have one discontinuity at the beginning, one sacred seed of an idea, and then blossom almost under their own power from that point.
    • A few implications of this obsevation.
    • First, the order of an argument matters.
    • Second, arguments that have more exposition can sometimes be better than ones with too little exposition.
    • Every bit of exposition, even if it follows naturally, has a chance of losing people just because they get bored.
    • Things that make people more likely to stick with an argument:
      • 1) they are intrinsically motivated, or
      • 2) the argument is enjoyable on its own (clever writing, evocative metaphors)