My pushups app held me hostage, so I made a new one.
- My pushups app held me hostage, so I made a new one.
- A few weeks ago I wanted to add pushups to my morning workout routine.
- The App Store has literally hundreds of apps that will count your pushups.
- You put the phone on the floor and each time you tap it with your nose it increments the count.
- They keep track of your current progression, and steadily increment the difficulty of sets.
- These apps are, uniformly, terrible.
- Most are festooned in comically obtrusive ads.
- Others, ludicrously, want you to pay a recurring subscription fee.
- A month ago I spent a few hours combing through the app store to find one that seemed to have the features I wanted with minimal cruft.
- The one I found had premium subscription-only features, but they were all things I didn't need, like being able to switch to a different level in the progression.
- I did 10 workouts without issue.
- Then, on the 10th one, when I opened the app, it reported that my current progression was 10 levels ahead of where I'd left off.
- That was such an aggressive progression that it would have been physically impossible with my current level of strength.
- So I went to swap the progression back to where I should be… and it told me I needed to become a subscriber.
- It seemed to mock me: "what are you going to do, lose your workout progress?"
- My immediate reaction was a boiling rage.
- So, I spent 10 minutes and vibe coded a better one for myself.
- Then I spent a couple of hours this week adding more features and polish.
- It's at https://floored.fitness, and will soon be in the App Store.
- Tagline: Bodyweight coach without the BS. 100% free. No ads. Forever.
- My idealistic hope is that this little act of protest will use the power of vibe-coding to forcibly de-enshittify a niche category of software, collapsing the business model of these scammers.
- This app holding me hostage is the apotheosis of a dynamic at the core of all same-origin software: the silo arbitrage.
- The more state you store in a given software's silo, the more power it holds over you.
- It can extract significant rent on your inability to leave, even holding you hostage.
- The pushup app holding is just a particularly egregious example.
- Blatant and very low value so clearly outrageous.
- But it exists everywhere.
- Let's use agentic engineering to de-enshittify software!